Skip to content

Research atlas for early Christianity. Claims are tagged attested, traditional, or disputed. Copyrighted full texts, including CCEL editions, are not included.

Council

Chalcedon

451 · Chalcedon

Attested. The definition and the votes are extensively recorded. What the definition meant, and whether it betrayed Cyril, was disputed immediately and still is.

Convened by. Marcian and Pulcheria

Issues. How to say that Christ is fully God and fully human after the crisis of 449, without returning to a split Christ or to a mixed nature.

Outcomes. A definition that Christ is acknowledged in two natures, without confusion, change, division, or separation, and that Leo's Tome agrees with Nicaea. Dioscorus was deposed, mainly for his conduct. Canon 28 renewed Constantinople's ranking, which Roman legates resisted. Many in Egypt and Syria rejected the definition. Churches that do are later called Oriental Orthodox; they are not 'monophysite' in the crude sense older textbooks used.

Canons or creeds. The definition is a doctrinal formula, not a list of biblical books. Canon 28 is jurisdictional and was disputed at the time.

Show Chalcedon on the map

Further reading

Also named, not in the vote columns

People

Sources

DeChurched Atlas — Early Christianity as history, from every source