Skip to content

Classroom view. Claims are tagged attested, traditional, or disputed. Copyrighted full texts are not included.

Bridge · Debates

eventtraditional

The 'Year of the Elephant': Abraha's march on Mecca (Q 105)

c. c. 552 – c. 570

Place: mecca

21.422, 39.826 · On the map

The Q 105 story and the 570 date are traditional. Campaigns in central Arabia in 552 are attested (Ry 506). Whether they are the same event is a scholarly debate.

Islamic tradition says Abraha attacked Mecca with an elephant in the year Muhammad was born (conventionally 570) and was turned back by birds sent by God, the story told in Sura 105. Inscriptions show Abraha really did campaign in central Arabia in 552. The date and the link to Mecca are debated.

People named here

  • Abraha
  • 'Abd al-Muttalib

Where scholars disagree

For

  • Lawrence I. Conrad — BSOAS 1987: the 570 date is a literary topos, and the campaign is earlier

Against

  • Christian Julien Robin — JSAI 2012: Ry 506 records a successful reconquest and should not simply be identified with the failed Elephant campaign

Links

People and office

Sequence

Conflict and authority

Sources

Coordinates are modern locations for ancient places. A gold circle is a region, not a surveyed gate.

DeChurched Atlas — Early Christianity as history, from every source